Eugenics in America
During
the “Progressive Era” of American history, many institutions saw a great deal
of change. The way that people thought about topics such as education, health
care, and civil rights began to see change. One idea that I feel was
particularly strange and wrong that came about during this time was Eugenics.
Eugenics
is the science of altering the reproductive processes of plants or animals to
produce new hybrids or breeds. In context to this time period of American history,
Eugenics was a way to create a “better” race. The concept became popular after
the civil war, supposedly because of all the social issues of the time period.
Society used genetics to explain these underlying problems and also as a means
for wealthy people to blame the world’s problems on genetics rather than the
structure of society.
The
history of Eugenics can be traced back to Sir Francis Galton, whom was a
distant relative of Charles Darwin. His book, The Right to Be Well Born,
contained a lot of the ideas that American Eugenics was based upon. In 1903,
the American Breeder’s Association was founded and began researching issues
that would have interested Sir Francis Galton himself. The ABA was the first
scientific organization in the United States to see the importance of Mendel’s
Laws and also the first organization to support Eugenic research. Shortly after
the ABA was founded, the American Eugenic Society was created. The AES was one
of the biggest supporters of the Eugenics movement, the organization had
committees for cooperation with clergymen, religious sermons, contests, crime
prevention, formal education and selective immigration.
Essentially,
the goal of Eugenicists and supporters of eugenics was to create a better America
through genetics. Scientists in favor of eugenics argued that society suffered
from the birth of “defective individuals.” Seeing how America is a free
country, it seems as if it would be hard to force eugenics into society, but it
wasn’t. At first, holocaust-like methods were suggested to rid society of less
desirable traits, but these plans never came to fruition. Eventually, the idea
of compulsory sterilization was introduced. Compulsory sterilization meant that
states could sterilize people that they did not want reproducing. Supporters
believed that the sterilization of one defective adult could save future
generations thousands of dollars. In return, 30 states adopted compulsory
sterilization laws which lead the sterilization of 60,000 U.S. citizens whom
were perceived as “disabled” by their state. From 1915-1935, 224 people were
sterilized in Alabama due to mental deficiencies. The state with the most
sterilizations, California, witnessed the sterilization of 20,108 citizens of
whom sixty percent were considered mentally ill and thirty five percent
mentally deficient.
The
craziest thing to me about Eugenics was the way it was popularized in America,
especially in the world of education. After 1914, Harvard, Columbia, Cornell
and Brown all offered courses on Eugenics. Even stranger, a content analysis of
high school textbooks from 1914 to 1948 showed that a majority of the textbooks
taught eugenics as if it were legitimate science. One particular high school
biology book had sections on Eugenics that recommended the policies of
immigration restriction, sterilization and race segregation. A Popular Science
article of the time period, written by a Syracuse professor, described the way
that many people felt that eugenics should actually be applied in college
classrooms. The professor claims that “The growth of the Eugenics movement,
both in Europe and America, within the recent decade is one of the most hopeful
signs of the day…” He then goes onto explain that the supporters of Eugenics
were actually angry with the fact that college had become more accessible for
people and that classes were leveled down by the less intelligent students.
Also, he states that nothing is more vital to a student’s success than his or
her heredity.
In the
social and business world, people were also rushing to show their support for
the movement. Kellogg’s Cereal funded the eugenics movement by creating the
Race Betterment Foundation and the Carnegie Foundation funded an effort to turn
eugenics into a method of altering human reproduction. Other books were written
as well such as
The Passing of the Great Race, written by Madison Grant,
which warned of the dangers of racial “mongrelization” and protecting the
purity of the Anglo-Saxon race. Movies, such as “The Black Stork” were now in
theaters around the country supporting sterilization. Sermons in church were
now subject to awards from the American Eugenic Society. Oddly enough, the
American Eugenic Society also held “Fitter Families” contests in which families
and individuals were scored and judged, then the best individuals and family
were given trophies. One such contest was held in Kansas, a progressive state
set out to breed better families, at the State Fair. The slogan for this
particular contest was “Fitter Families for Future Firesides” and its goal was
to get people to view Eugenics as a way of viewing your stock for future
parenthood.
The
idea of Eugenics is completely absurd to me because we in America viewed it has
a
The Day Book, a Chicago Newspaper of
the time, stated that eugenics was a “very small title in the science of
criminology.” Which makes me feel a little bit better about the past and the
way we treated people, in the sense that at least someone realized what we were
doing to our own people was wrong.
progressive thing, yet 10 years later when the Germans were doing it, it was
horrific. An author who wrote in
Creighton.edu
– History of Eugenics, how people of the time period viewed Eugenics and how the different social classes had different viewpoints.
Google
Books – Popular Science Eugenics, viewpoint of a professor from the time period
Online
News Paper Archive LOC – The Day Book (magazine in Chicago) on Eugenics, a viewpoint of an author who is against Eugenics
Eugenics
Archive – Popularization of Eugenics, information on Eugenic propaganda and a brief history of the origin
Textbook -- Brief Background of Eugenics